QUEER
​I MUBI Canada I December 13, 2024 I 135 mins. I
78%
Daniel Craig, Drew Starkey, Lesley Manville, Jason Schwartzman,
Henrique Zaga, Omar Apollot​​​
* As of 10/28/24
CAST:
DIRECTOR (S):
Lee, who recounts his life in Mexico City among American expatriate college students and bar owners surviving on part-time jobs and GI Bill benefits. He is driven to pursue a young man named Allerton, who is based on Adelbert Lewis Marker.
TIFF REVIEW BY: Darren Zakus - 10/29/24
RATING 2.5 out of 5
Queer allows Daniel Craig and Drew Starkey to give awards worthy performances that make Luca Guadagnino’s artist direction an intoxicating experience, but the confused, rushed and poorly paced narrative squanders any of the film’s potential.
Fans of Luca Guadagnino are in for a treat this year. Only a few months after his last film Challengers hit theatres and introduced viewers to a sweaty and sexy world of competitive tennis, Guadagnino is already back with his next film, this time adapting William S. Burroughs semi-autobiographical novel Queer. From the second the film begins, it’s unequivocally a Guadagnino film with its beautiful artistic vision, while Daniel Craig and especially Drew Starkey deliver excellent performances, but this is not the film viewers will expect it to be. Instead of the racy, homosexual romance featuring explicit sex scenes that audiences are expecting, it’s a quiet meditation on loneliness and drug addiction, that attempts to juggle tonally different storylines that creates for a thematically disorienting film that will leave audiences questioning what the aim of this story was.
As with all of Guadagnino’s films, Queer is an artistic feast for all of the viewer’s senses. The cinematography captures the loneliness of Craig’s Lee as he wanders the streets of Mexico searching for companionship with a beauty that draws the audience into the world of Burrough’s novel. Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, collaborating once again with Guadagnino following this year’s Challengers, have composed an atmospheric musical score that echoes Lee’s longing for connection that is the most intoxicating element of the film. Throw in some great needle drops, including one absolutely sublime use of Nirvana’s “Come As You Are”, Queer is as excellently executed as all of Guadagnino’s previous films.
Going into this awards season, lots of attention was being placed on Craig’s performance, and it is without question a great performance. Much like his quiet character who wanders the streets of Mexico City looking for connection, Craig embodies a melancholic stillness as he looks for companionship. Despite the tight knit and seemingly welcome gay community present in Mexico City, Lee chooses to forge his own path as he pursues an interest with the alluring young Eugene Allerton, played by Starkey, and it allows Craig to tap into a vulnerability that we don’t often see from him. Craig bares it all in his performance, both physically and figuratively, as he balances Lee’s self destructive drug addiction with his self-inflicted isolation in pursuit of a relationship that is evidently not being reciprocated. Leaving more unsaid with his performance creating a physical embodiment of loneliness that helps to create the heart of the film’s story. It's a great performance from Craig that showcases his range of an actor outside of the James Bond and Knives Out series, and while it’s not a career best performance from Craig, it’s unequivocally the rawest one we’ve seen from him that should propel him into the awards conversation.
While the focus will be on Craig’s performance, it is Starkey who steals the film as Allerton. From the second he appears on screen, Starkey has an immediate allure and sex appeal that allows the audience to understand Lee’s instant attraction to him, only amplified by that Nirvana needle drop that begins booming on the cinema’s sound system as he appears in the nightclub in the film’s first act. The intense looks Starkey gives as Allerton captures Lee’s excitement and that of the viewer as there is a mystery to him, there is also a coldness to him that makes Lee’s pursuit of him a tragic one as it’s clear after their first night together that Allerton has no real interest in Starkey beyond killing time and to fulfill a desire with him for some adventure. It’s a striking performance that you can’t take your eyes off of, promising a great career ahead for Starkey as he continues to take on challenging and more complex roles. The supporting cast packs some serious talent with stars like Lesley Manville, Jason Schwartzman and Henry Zaga, all of whom are great, especially Schwartzman and Manville who are unrecognizable at first. But all of them have smaller roles with not much more than a scene or two, leaving the burden of carrying the film on Craig and Starkey, who do so with ease.
For those audiences who are not familiar with Burroughs’ novel, it’s not the film they are expecting based on the title. With a name like Queer and coming from Guadagnino, there is an expectation that this is going to be one steamy film full of passion and explicit sex scenes, and you wouldn’t be wrong during the film’s first chapter. But the latter two chapters feature a tonal shift that subvert expectations, first dealing with Lee’s drug addiction and the rejection for Allerton, before turning into an iowaska seeking and fuelled journey through jungles of South America. It starts off as a period character drama before turning into a full blown Ari Aster hallucination fueled trip, and it severely hurts the film’s pacing which brings it to a halt in the second chapter. Even with this shorter version of the story than what Guadagnino shot, the ever changing narrative focus makes the film feel very long as there are two distinct films occurring with Queer, and they don’t mix well together. The first, which is what the audience expects in the first chapter, is deeply sensual, intoxicating and engaging as we first meet Lee and are introduced to this specific subset of Mexico City. But after the first chapter ends, the film becomes cold and hollow as the audience learns that Lee’s pursuit of Allerton is destined to fail, before becoming a crazy experience in the final chapter. Was the film about Lee’s destructive tendencies looking for love in the wrong places that only isolated further from a community that wanted to accept him? Was it about his struggle with drug addiction and his inability to replace it with sexual activities that pops up out of nowhere in the second chapter? Or was it about the mind freeing powers of iowaska? Well, we may never know. Without question the story feels unfinished given how quickly everything wraps up and Allerton is completely cast aside as a character, that I’m sure would benefit from a longer cut from Guadagnino, but even so, it would not be enough to salvage what is destined to be one of the most divisive films of the year as it is unclear what Guadagnino wanted to say with this story.
Never for a second missing Luca Guadagnino’s cinematic flair that has made him one of the most revered art house directors in recent years, Queer is a perplexing experience. From a production point of view, the film is impeccably made and features exemplary technicals from the cinematography to the musical score Trent Reznor and Atticus Ross, while Daniel Craig and Drew Starkey both deliver excellent performances. Though it’s not enough to make an inherently cold and thematically jumbled story an enticing watch, leaving Queer void of real meaning that sadly wastes the talents of Daniel Craig and Drew Starkey and makes Luca Guadagnino’s latest film a beautifully made misfire that art house film lovers won’t be able to stop dissecting