top of page

I PLAY ROCKY

November 20, 2026 / Elevation Pictures / 128 mins.

IMDB_Logo_2016.svg.png
rottentomatoes_logo_40.336d6fe66ff (1).png

CAST: Anthony Ippolito, Matt Dillon, AnnaSophia Robb, P.J. Byrne, Toby Kebbell, Tracy Letts, Jay Duplass, Stephan James

DIRECTOR(S): Peter Farrelly

The film is an electrifying true story about an unknown actor with an unshakable belief that he wasn’t just meant to write Rocky—he was meant to be Rocky Balboa. Told “no” at every turn, Sylvester Stallone bets everything on himself, holding the line on playing the lead against seemingly impossible odds. The result is the ultimate underdog story behind the ultimate underdog movie.

Written By Kurt Morrison / November 13, 2026

Rating 4.5 out of 5

Very few films, let alone franchises, have burned themselves into the pop culture psyche quite like Rocky. The run up the steps. The raw eggs. "Yo, Adrian!". Bill Conti's trumpets that somehow make taking out the recycling feel like a title fight.


Rocky isn't just a movie at this point, it's a piece of Americana, right up there with apple pie, baseball and yelling at your TV on a Sunday. So making a movie about how that movie got made is a bold move. It's a bit like painting a portrait of the Mona Lisa: people already know what it's supposed to look like, and they'll notice if you get the smile wrong.


I first caught I Play Rocky back in September at this year's Toronto International Film Festival, and it stuck with me long after the festival madness died down. Part of that is the crowd-pleasing true story of a broke, stubborn nobody who refused to sell his script unless he got to star in it. Part of it is the performances.


Tonight I went back for round two, and it's another case of a second viewing making something better. My TIFF screening was already memorable, but this time I got to sit back and enjoy the standout performances and how simply the story is told, without the festival buzz ringing in my ears. Turns out this one has a better chin than I gave it credit for.


Let's talk about the kid to begin.


Anthony Ippolito's performance is spectacular and something very special: an almost uncanny mimic of Stallone in both look and sound. The slur, the swagger, the puppy-dog eyes hiding a guy who is absolutely not taking no for an answer. Ippolito doesn't just play Sly, he seems to have been built from his spare parts. It'll be a tough sell for a Best Actor nomination at year's end because the field is so stacked. But if Rami Malek can lip sync his way to winning an Oscar, why can't this kid at least get a nomination for literally becoming Sylvester Stallone? At the very least, give the man a participation trophy and a raw egg smoothie.


The supporting players hold their own too. AnnaSophia Robb is fantastic as Sasha, the wife who believes in Sly back when believing in him was a very questionable investment. She brings real warmth to a role that could easily have been "Supportive Wife #1." Toby Kebbell is just as good as producer Robert Chartoff, and it's great to see him back in action. It feels like a while since I've seen him in something this big, so welcome back, Toby, we missed you. P.J. Byrne is a fun sparring partner for him as fellow producer Irwin Winkler, and together the two of them make the business side of Hollywood almost as entertaining as the boxing. Stephan James struts in as Carl Weathers with all the confidence of Apollo Creed, Matt Dillon brings some grit as Frank Stallone Sr., and Jay Duplass is a treat as director John Avildsen. It's a strong bench, and nobody throws a lazy punch - which is wild to see and even say in today's film landscape because no films nowadays pack this kind of a deep roster (.... that whole ending there^ was a sports team reference for those of you who don't understand wtf I'm talking about).


Now for the not-so-great part. The direction is very copy/paste, and that's no knock on Peter Farrelly. It's just a very formulaic biopic in its plot, cinematography and direction. If you've seen one "plucky dreamer beats the system" movie, you know every beat here before it lands. Again, that's not necessarily a bad thing, since formulas exist because they work. But it's hard to call this one of the year's best films when it isn't necessarily a well-made movie. It's a crowd-pleasing movie, and those aren't always the same thing.


That said, this does feel Oscar bait-y in all the right ways: a true story, a transformative lead performance and a big swelling finale built for standing ovations. It'll be interesting to see if it can catch fire over American Thanksgiving week and build some legs heading into awards season.


Either way, I Play Rocky is the definition of a crowd pleaser, and the fact that it doesn't only cater to Rocky fans says a lot about its quality. You don't need to know your Drago from your Clubber Lang to get swept up in it. All you need is a soft spot for underdogs, and if you don't have one of those, I'm not sure what you're doing at the movies anyways.

bottom of page